All Things Return

On the surface, the Tao is impractical, illogical

Painting: All Things Return
Original and print available.

All Things Return

Morning opens its hand and the light spills outward.
The breath leaves the body like a traveler who trusts the road.
No arc bends forever forward.
Petals curl back to seed, rivers remember the sea,
and every arising carries its own homecoming.

Return is not defeat but the Tao’s own rhythm —
each departure already pregnant with arrival,
each flourishing a promise of repose.

Reflection

There is a moment on a northern river, just before dark, when you can feel things shift. All day the current has carried you forward — past granite ledges, through stands of spruce, over the glassy backs of deep pools where brook trout hold in the cold. You have been moving outward, into the world, into distance. And then the light changes subtly. The wind, which blew downstream all afternoon, softens and turns. The birds that sang at dawn begin again, as if the day were not ending but circling back to where it started. You rest your paddle across the gunwales and sit still, and for a moment you feel it — the whole world exhaling, and then, without effort, drawing breath again.

The Chinese call this fu — return. It is one of the oldest ideas in Taoist thought. We tend to think of return as going backward, as retreat, as something that happens when forward motion fails. But returning is the movement of the Tao. Not a secondary motion. Not a correction. The primary gesture of all things. The out-breath does not fail when it becomes the in-breath. The tide does not lose its nerve when it turns. October is not a defeat for the maple tree. These are not reversals. They are completions.

Chapter 16 of the Tao Te Ching asks us to observe this directly. All things flourish, and each returns to its root. Returning to the root is stillness. Stillness is returning to what is. This passage has been a touchstone for contemplatives for twenty-five centuries, and I think the reason is simple: it describes something we already know in our bodies but have forgotten with our minds. Every breath we take is a small lesson in fu. Every night of sleep. Every season. The pattern is so constant, so intimate, that we stop seeing it — the way you stop hearing a river after you have camped beside it long enough.

Meditation is, in many ways, a practice of recovering this awareness. You sit. The mind reaches outward — into plans, memories, worries, desires. It surges like the green shoots in the poem, claiming, blooming into the ten thousand names. And then, if you let it, it turns. Not because you force it. Because returning is what minds do, the way returning is what breath does, when you stop interfering. The thought arises, reaches its crest, and dissolves. Another follows. You begin to notice that the dissolution is not a problem to be solved. It is the other half of the rhythm. It is where the stillness lives.

I remember a morning in the Adirondacks, early fall, when I sat on a rock ledge above a lake and watched the mist. It rose off the water in slow columns, drifted upward through the hemlocks, and vanished. An hour later it returned as rain — soft, barely audible, beading on the moss at my feet. The water had gone out and come home. Nothing was lost. Nothing was added. The whole cycle was one seamless motion, and sitting there I had the strange, quiet sense that I was watching something the Tao Te Ching had been trying to tell me for years.

This is what the poem means when it says that every departure is already pregnant with arrival. The seed does not become the flower and then, separately, become the seed again. The whole arc is one thing. The flourishing and the releasing are not two movements but a single breath, the way a wave is not two events — a rising and a falling — but one gesture of the water.

There is deep comfort in this, but it is not a sentimental comfort. It asks something of us. It asks us to stop clinging to the outward phase — the blooming, the building, the reaching — as if it were the only real part of living. It asks us to recognize that the gathering-in is equally alive, equally sacred. The autumn of a project. The silence after a conversation. The fallow season when nothing seems to be growing but the roots are deepening in the dark. These are not empty spaces between the meaningful moments. They are the Tao completing its circle.

Sit with this. Watch your breath for a few minutes — not to control it, but to observe its rhythm. Notice how the exhale does not crash into the inhale. There is a turning point, almost imperceptible, where the outward motion simply becomes the inward motion, without effort, without announcement. That turning point is fu. That small, silent pivot is the movement of the Tao, happening inside your own body, right now, whether you attend to it or not.

The question is not whether you will return. You will. Everything does. The question is whether you will return with awareness — whether you will feel the great wheel turning and know yourself as part of it, not a stone carried along by the current but the current itself, going out in splendor and coming home to source, endlessly, gently, whole.

Questions to Consider

Lao Tzu suggests that returning to the root is stillness, and that stillness is a form of knowing. Have you ever experienced a period of apparent emptiness or inactivity that turned out to be quietly generative — a fallow season that was preparing something you could not yet see?

The reflection describes how the mind, in meditation, surges outward into thought and then turns back on its own when we stop interfering. In your own experience of sitting quietly — or journaling, walking, or any contemplative practice — what happens when you stop trying to direct the mind and simply let it complete its arc?

The poem says that every flourishing contains within it a promise of repose. Does that idea bring you comfort, resistance, or something more complicated?

Is there something in your life right now that is asking to return — a habit, a belief, an ambition, an attachment — that you have been holding in its outward phase longer than it wants to stay? What might it look like to let the tide turn?

To view this on the Zen Mountain Journal website where the image is larger, visit here.

. . .